Lawyers representing a group of asylum seekers in the United Kingdom on Monday told the Court of Appeal in London that Britain’s plan to send migrants to Rwanda was unlawful.
One of their lawyers, Raza Husain argued that Rwanda was an authoritarian one-party state that did not tolerate opposition and imprisons, tortures, and murders opponents.
“There will only be any form of deterrent effect if a third country to which asylum seekers are removed is one to which they would not wish to go,” Husain said, arguing the government had failed to tread the line between deterring migrants and remaining within Britain’s human rights obligations.
The British government last year revealed plans to send thousands of migrants to the East African country as part of a 120 million pound ($148 million) deal to deter asylum seekers from crossing the English Channel from France in small boats.
A last-minute decision by the European Court of Human Rights, which placed an injunction banning any deportations until the conclusion of legal proceedings in Britain, prevented the first scheduled flight to Rwanda from taking off in June of last year.
The High Court in London decided the program was legal in December, but some human rights organizations and asylum seekers from countries like Syria, Sudan, Iraq, Iran, and Vietnam are challenging that ruling.
But lawyers representing the asylum seekers say the government’s argument that Rwanda is a “safe third country” is flawed.
But the British government lawyers insisted that the deal with Rwanda was “subject to an exacting set of monitoring arrangements”, including by the UN High Commissioner for Refugees, who has intervened in the appeal.
They said in court filings that evidence about Rwanda’s asylum system was of little relevance as it had no bearing on how asylum seekers would be dealt with under the deal with Britain.
Meanwhile, one of three judges hearing the case, Ian Burnett, the Lord Chief Justice said the issue of the safety of Rwanda would be the core issue.
Last year, a record 45,000 migrants entered Britain in small boats. Finding a solution to the issue of illegal immigration is one of Prime Minister Rishi Sunak’s top concerns.